Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Media Law
Media Law
70
Law
Undergraduate 3
09/17/2010

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
Rule of law
Definition

 

·         system of rules of conduct for individuals and institutions with punishment for those who violate those rules

1-Constitution

2-Federal law

3-Rules and regulations / administrative law

4-court cases

5-executive order

6-common law

 

Term
Constitution
Definition
base of law
Term
Federal statute
Definition

 

law enacted by a legislature (legislative law), or passed by Congress and signed by the president

 

Term
Common law
Definition

 

unwritten law based on tradition or precedent

 

Term
Stare decisis
Definition

 

·         let it stand, in order to change something, you need good reasoning

-encourages consistent, predictable application of law

 

Term
Federalism
Definition

·         sharing of power, i.e. b/t fed and state

Term

 supremacy clause

Definition

o   States are bound by congressional statuteso   State/local law that contradicts fed law is invalid unless courts make ruling

Term

 Independent judiciary

Definition

o   Separate from other gov’t branches

o   Independent  of public opinion b/c they are not elected

o   Appointed by president, approved by congress, served for life

o   Can only be removed by impeachment

Term

Creation of laws

Definition

 

subcommitteeàfull committeeàhouse

 

Term
Tort
Definition

·         dealing with a wrongdoing b/t 2 private parties

o   i.e. libel, privacy

o   inadvertent negligence

Term
writ certiorari
Definition
Term
certiorari den
Definition

o   denial to hear, doesn’t mean they agree with the first decision

Term
censorship
Definition
prior restraint by gov't
Term

John Zenger

Definition

 

o   1730s-publised an unfavorable report of governor of NY, governor takes him to court

§  Andrew Hamilton-argues it’s the truth, thus it’s not libel

§  Jury rules against the law (jury nullification), in favor of Zenger

First free speech precedent

-established the right to criticize gov't as long as the accusations are true

 

Term

US v. O’Brien

Definition

o   Dealing w/ nat’l security

o   Overturned the lower court

o   Protest wasn’t illegal, but burning card was

o   O’Brien test

Term
First amendment
Definition

·         nearly absolute protection of speech

Term

 Alien and Sedition Act

Definition

o   Late 18th century

o   Made criticism of gov’t/gov’t officials illegal

Term

 

 Time, place, manner

O'Brien Test

Definition

 

1.  Content must be neutral

            2.  gotta leave a door open, an alternative

            3.  gov’t must have substantial interest in the case

            4.  rules must be narrowly tailored

 

Term

 Schenck v. US-1919

Definition

§  Sedition rules

§  Schenck-head of Phil communist party

§  Printed out pamphlets to encourage people to avoid the draft

§  Law said it’s illegal to disrupt military

§  “clear and present danger”-go to jail

Term

 

 Gitlow v. NY-1925

 

Definition

 


§  Gitlow-socialist

-upheld conviction b/c it endangered the government

-however it established incorporation-14th amendment regarding due process applied to states, thus protecting first amendment rights

 

Term

 

 Near v. Minn-1931

 

Definition

 

§  1st sc decision dealing with freedom of press

§  Near, editor of Sat press, was criticizing gov’t officials about bootlegging and gambling

-State banning of paper is unconstitutional

-State law was essence of censorship

-prior restraint is the least tolerable form of government intervention in the speech marketplace 

Term

 

 Brandenburg v. OH, 1969

 

Definition

 

§ last sedition case

Overturned KKK leader’s conviction

§  Difference b/t criticism and speech that presents inaminant danger

§  4 points: gov’t has to prove all 4 to convict incitement

·         The intent of the speaker is to induce incitement

·         Very little time b/t speech/article and action

·         The conduct of the call is illegal

·         There is a high probability that the illegal action will happen

 

Term

 NY Times v. US

Definition

§  Gov’t didn’t have burden of proof of nat’l security

Term

·         What a libel plaintiff must demonstrate to win

Definition

1.      The info in question must be an assertion of fact, ex:  she’s a slut, NOT I’ve heard she’s a slut

2.      Published

3.      If it concerned the plaintiff

4.      Defamatory-not positive

5.      False

6.      Defendant was at fault

Term
libel per se
Definition

  terms that are negative no matter the context

Term
libel per quod
Definition

a.       what most cases are, matters what the context is 

Term
Kalin
Definition

-libel per quod

o   Picture caption in nat’l inquire

o   “it” could mean murder or perjury

o   Meaning of the term depends on what the average readers thinks it is

Term

The speech act

Definition

o   Makes foreign libel judgments unenforceable here unless they match the first amendment

o   Protect Americans from different libel laws in other countries

 

Term

·         NY Times v. Sullivan

Definition

o   Malice-had to knowingly publish something that was false

o   Takes away seditious libel, libel against public official

Term

 

o   Curtis Publishing v. Butts

o   AP v.  Walker

 

Definition

 

o   Together defined who is covered under Times v. Sullivan

o  broadened times v. sullivan to mean pub figs

 

Term
All purpose
Definition

§  someone who occupies a position of power or influence, i.e. fame, typically include movie stars, athletes

Term
limited purpose
Definition

§  somebody who has been involved in a public controversy and their participation tried to influence public opinion

Term
Boot-strapping
Definition

·         when plaintiff (media) tries to pull a defendant into public controversy

Term

 Jewell v. Cox

Definition

o   Made him a limited purpose public official

o   Atl papers made comments about accusation

o   Jewell sued

o   Out of court

o   Not legal precedent

Term

 Malice

Definition

o   If you get sued for malice, courts can look at your docs, violation of 1st amendment, chilling effect

o   Flipside-how else are you going to prove it?

Term

 Curtis Publishing v. Butts

Definition

§  Saturday evening post

§  1964-published an article that accused two coaches (one is Butts) of fixing a game b/t Bama and GTech

§  No one at the magazine talked to either coach

§  Story based on someone overhearing something during a phone call

§  Gross negligence, Butts won

Term

 Negligence

Definition

§  Careless editing

§  Misreading

§  Didn’t check sources

Term

Pro-curium 

Definition

o   A decision by the court in full written by one judge but not signed.

Term

Factors that determine the freedom of a specific medium

Definition

·         The capacity of a medium to carry messages

·         Relationship between medium and government

·         Pervasiveness

·         Accessibility by children

 

Term

 

Ad hoc balancing

 

Definition

 

·         Making decisions according to the specific facts of the case under review rather than more general principles

 

 

Term

 

Categorical balancing

 

Definition

 

·         A judge’s or court’s practice of developing rules by weighing different broad categories, such as political speech, against other categories of interests, such as privacy. The rules may be applied in later cases with similar facts.

o   Judge looks beyond the speech itself to consider the particular circumstances and the extent of harm caused to determine whether the expression falls into a punishable category.

 v

 

Term

 

Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire

 

Definition

 

·         The court did not fully develop different “narrow” categories of speech – what would fall under free speech and what wouldn’t etc.

o   Later – political speech has full constitutional protection

o   Seditious speech, fighting words, obscenity and defamation are not protected.

 

 

Term

 

Seditious libel (sedition) 

 

Definition

 

·         Communication meant to incite people to change the government; criticism of the government

o   Criticizing government or officials

§  John Peter Zenger

 

Term

Gertz v. Welch 

Definition

·         Anybody whether in the public eye or not, public official or not, had to prove that the media were at fault.

·         John Birch Society – conservative group

o   Run by Robert Welch

·         Claimed Gertz was a communist, had a police record, tried to frame a local policeman

o   Court determined Gertz was not a public figure,

§  He would have to show gross negligence on the part of the Birch magazine if he wanted to collect punitive damages. 

Term
Tinker v. Des Moine School District
Definition

-black armbands protesting Vietnam, they were suspended

-fear of potential disruption was not enough reason to infringe on students' right of expression

-Tinker test-right of schools to limit 1st amendment rights of students

Term
Bethel School District v. Fraser
Definition

-using sexual metaphors in speech for student govt

-suspended

-words threatened the values and purpose of the school at a school sponsored event

Term
Morse v. Frederick
Definition

-"Bong Hits 2 Jesus" banner

-sign threatened and disobeyed school's anti-drug policy and therefore put school and policy in danger

Term
Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier
Definition

-principal moved two stories from school newspapers about divorced parents and supreme court

-ruled that advisers that oversaw the production of the student newspaper had the right to make decisions about the content

Term
HS Cases
Definition

established specific and "special environments", such as pub hs, may limit the range to which we can exercise freedom of speech

-students can be restricted based on their speech's effect on school environment and students

-limit 1st amendment rights of students

Term
Texas Beef v. Oprah
Definition

-veggie laws

-post-production editing

-court reaffirmed the legal precedent that opinion is protected by 1st amendment as long as the opinion has factual basis

-case declared that production companies could not be held liable when they edited their broadcasts to leave some segments in and out

Term

 

 Jewell v. Cox

 

Definition
Term
bootstrapping
Definition

 

media is sued by someone and after the fact pulls that individual into some sort of public controversy in order to change their status (illegal)

 

Term
SLAPP
Definition

– usually used to make the media or people stop talking/ being critical

Threats to take libel action

Defendants win 90% of the time

Rising trend in the use of SLAPP suits as a took of corporations

Rising unhappiness with the media lately 

Term
Privileged Communication
Definition

media that is covering an official public proceeding (town hall meeting, senate vote, etc.)

People have a right to know about the proceeding (as long as its covered truthfully)

Senators’ comments on the senate floor is absolutely privileged

Libel suits cannot be brought for fair and accurate reports about official public proceedings

Term
absolute privilege
Definition

Congressman is immune on Senate floor (NOT outside)

includes state legislation

petitions to official body (municipal, state, fed)

court proceedings

Term
Qualified/Conditional Privelege
Definition

-article that is talking ABOUT an official proceeding – expressing reactions, concerns, opinions

stories must be balanced

-protection only applies when talking about proceeding specifically

Term

 

Milkovich v. Lorain Journal (1974)

 

Definition

Lorain Journal said Coach Milkovich lied at a hearing

Milkovich appealed 3 times à won libel suit

Court Decision = NOT clear cut

Question = whether the Journal was reporting fact or opinion

Term

 

Ollman v. Evans (1985)

 

Definition

-Concerned potential PSC academic chair at UMD à offer was revoked

-Gives us a test of OPINION

CONTEXT à The Ollman Test

-Can a statement be proved true or false

-What is the common ordinary meaning of the word at issue

-Journalistic context of what was said

-What is the social context of the remarks

Political debate, protest

Term
fair comment
Definition

-argues that when someone is in the public light, they automatically run the risk of comment about their profession (CONTEXT always critical) **Applies best with reviews & critiques (but not limited to)

-If a critic goes beyond personal comment about the profession, book, restaurant, etc. à that is not fair comment

-Does the comment focus on the public interest?

Ex. Information that may persuade/dissuade attending a concert

Term

 

Media will not get into trouble if the following is true…

 

Definition

-Story is newsworthy (of interest to the public)

-The accusation, criticism, negative comment is made by a responsible group or medium

-Negative comment is made about a pubic official, figure or organization

-The story is accurate

-Tone of story is NEUTRAL

 

Term
Wire Service Defense
Definition
If the AP makes a mistake and local stations pick up the story with little or no change, AP is liable – NOT the local media outlets
Term
statute of limitation
Definition
you must take legal action relatively quickly, within the time frame stated in the local statute
Term
Summary Judgment
Definition

-petition a judge to issue a judgment based on the facts presented to him or her

-¾ of media requests for summary judgments are given

-B/c there isn’t enough evidence, public figure, etc.

Term
Question Jurisdiction
Definition
: challenge the location of where the libel case is being tried
Term
arbitration
Definition
when 2 parties agree to accept a decision made by a neutral 3rd party (instead of going to court)
Term
actual damages
Definition

losses you can prove

Idea is to reimburse the plaintiff

Usually smaller amount of money

Term
punitive damages
Definition

designed as a deterrent, to send a message

Much larger $ amounts

Encourage being responsible 

Supporting users have an ad free experience!