Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Civil Procedure I Cases
Case Names and Rules Keyed to Ides and May 2d
42
Law
Graduate
12/13/2007

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
Pennoyer v Neff
Definition
Personal jurisdiction can be obtained by serving a person within the territory of the forum state, or by voluntary appearance.
Term
Hess v Pawloski
Definition
Personal jurisdiction can be aquired by non-resident motorist statute.
Term
Harris v Balk
Definition
The situs of the debt moves with the debtor.
Term
International Shoe
Definition
A person must have such minimum contacts with a state so that requiring him to appear would not offend fair play and substantial justice.
Term
Hanson v Denkla
Definition
The defendant must do something to purposefully avail himself of the laws and protection of the state.
Term
Burger King
Definition
A person should reasonably anticipate defending a suit in the forum when his contacts with the forum are systematic and continuous.
Term
Chalek v Klein
Definition
Due process does not allow states to maintain jurisdiction over noresident buyers, where the buyers are passive purchasers.
Term
World-Wide VW
Definition
Unilateral activity cannot establish jurisdiction (P's driving of car into OK).
Term
Asahi
Definition

Split Decision

 

O'Conner's Stream of Commerce Plus - D must doe somthing more than place product in the stream of commerce.

 

Brennan's Pure Stream of Commerce - Placing product in the stream of commerce is enough.

Term
Calder v Jones
Definition

State can maintainpersonal jurisdiction over D if effect of D's act is felt in state.

 

  1. Intentional tort
  2. D directed at the forum.
  3. Brunt of harm felt in forum.
Term
Revell v Lidov
Definition

Zippo Test (website interactivity)

 

Three types:

  • Doing busines over the net
  • Interactive (forums)
  • Passive (information)
Term
Perkins v Benguet
Definition
A state may exercise general jurisdiction if a D's contacts with that state are so systematic and continuous (so related) that it is reasonable for them to expect to be hauled into court there.
Term
Helicopteros v Hall
Definition

 

 The lower the contacts, the greater they must be in relation to the forum for general jurisdiction.

 

[image]

Term

Nowak v Tak How

(scope of specific jurisdiction)

Definition
A state may exercise jurisdiction over a party when that person has limited contacts which have a substantial connection to the claim against him.
Term
Shaffer v Heitner
Definition
The Int'l Shoe minimum contacts test applies to quasi in rem actions.
Term
Burnham v Superior
Definition

A state may exercise jurisdiction over a person located within its borders.

 

(Argument between Scalia and Brennan over tradition and contemporary law.)

Term

Nowak v Tak How

(Reasonableness)

Definition

Gestalt Factors

 

  1. Burden on D
  2. Interest of Forum
  3.  P's Covenience
  4. Judicial Systems Interest
  5. Affected Government's Interests
Term
AICPA v Affinity
Definition
Person served under Rule 4(h) must be a representative so integrated with the organization that he will know what to do with the papers.
Term
Mullane v Central Hanover
Definition
Was notice reasonably calculated under all of the circumstance to apprise interested parties.
Term
Jones v Flowers
Definition
When mailed notice of tax sale or foreclosure is returned undelivered, the government must do something more.
Term
Mennonite Board of Missions
Definition
Constructive notice is not adequate when the name and address of the interested party is known.
Term
Underwood Farmers v Leidholm
Definition
Waiver of service must be made knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently.
Term
Connecticut v Doehr
Definition

Must hold pre-attachment hearing, unless there is some great reason.

 

Must look at:

  1. D's interests
  2. Risk of Erroneous Attachment
  3. P's Interests 
Term
American Well Works
Definition
Case "arises under" when federal law creates the cause of action.
Term
Grable & Sons v Darue
Definition

An Essential Federal Ingredient exists in a state cause of action when:

 

  1. Necessity - A federal issue is necessary to state the claim.
  2. Actually Disputed -The federal issue is actually disputed.
  3. Federal Expertise - The federal issue is substantial.
  4. Disruptiveness - The issue must not interupt fed/state balance.
Term
Louisville v Mottley
Definition

Well Pleaded Complaint Rule

 

Only the necessary elements of a claim will be considered in determining if the case arises under federal law. Defenses raised in P's complaint wil be ignored.

Term
Skelly Oil
Definition

An action for declaratory relief would arise under 1331 if a suit for damages would raise the issue.

 

  1. Determine which of the parties would have been the P seeking coercive relief.
  2. Run either the creation test or the essential federal ingredient test.
Term
Strawbridge v Curtis
Definition

Complete diversity needed for 1332 purposes.

 

All parties on one side of the "v" must be from different states than all parties on the other side of the "v".

Term
Lundquist v Precision Valley Aviation
Definition

Domicile = Citizenship

 

Domicile is:

  1. Person takes up residence somewhere.
  2. Intends to remain there indefinitely. 
Term
Tubbs V SWB
Definition

Corporations citizenship is its state of incorporation and its principle place of business.

 

Total Activity Test:

Look at total activity of business and apply either the Nerve Center test or the Activity Test

Term
Carden v Arkoma
Definition
Unincorporated associations and organizations are citizens of every state and country of which any of its members is a citizen.
Term
Grupo Dataflux v Atlas
Definition
Citizenship determined at the time of filing.
Term
Coventry Sewage v Dworkin
Definition

The amount needed to satisfy 1332 is determined at the time of filing.

 

Good Faith Test - if P had no reason to know that the amount in contoversy was wrong.

 

Legal Certainty Test - if it is apparent from the face of the pleadings, to a "legal certainty" that the plaintiff cannot recover or was never entitled to the amount in the complaint, then the case will be dismissed.

Term
United Mine Workers v Gibbs
Definition

Fed. Ct may exercise jurisdicton over a case with federal and state components when:

 

  1. The fed. claim "arises under"
  2. The claim meets SMJ
  3. The claims are CNOF related
  4. Claims are such that they would reasonably be expected to be tried as a whole.
Term
Owen Equip. v Kroger
Definition
There must be complete diversity for supplimental jurisdiction cases.
Term
McCurtain County Prod. v Cowett
Definition

All D's to the suit must join removal or none may remove.

  

Term
Salei v Boardwalk
Definition

Rules 1441(c) unconstitutional.

 

1441(c) extends jurisdiction beyond the outrbounds of Art. III, Sec. 2. Gibbs gives rule that CNOF related causes are at the extent of Art. III. Anything beyond that is unconstitutional.

Term
First of Michigan v Bramlett
Definition
Venue is proper wherever a substantial portion of the events occurred.
Term
Smith v Colonial Penn
Definition

Convenience of parties and witnesses and interests of justice must substantially outweigh P's choice of forum.

 

Factors:

  • Availability of parties and witnesses
  • Location of counsel
  • Locaton of records
  • Location of wrong
  • P's choice of forum
Term
Bremen v Zapata
Definition
Party objecting to venue must show enforcement would be unreasonable and unjust.
Term
Jones v GNC
Definition
If state has a strong policy against forum selection clauses, it will not be enforced.
Term
Piper Aircraft v Reyno
Definition

The possibility of an unfavorable change in law does not bar dismissal on the ground of forum non conveniens - except where the remedy would be clearly unsatisfactory.

 

 

Supporting users have an ad free experience!