Shared Flashcard Set

Details

Administrative Law: Chevron
N/A
16
Law
Professional
05/04/2015

Additional Law Flashcards

 


 

Cards

Term
Outline
Definition
  • 2 steps of Chevron 
  • Express v. implicit delegation
  • Brown v. Williamson (step 1)
  • Young v. Community Nutrition (step 2)
  • INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca (step 1)
  • Babbitt (step 2)
  • Mead
  • Skidmore
  • Hearst 
Term
FDA v. Brown and Williamson Tobacco
Definition
  • Chevron Step 1 
  • FDA issued rule designed to prevent marketing of tobacco products to young people
  • Congress foreclosed removal of tobacco from market --> Congress spoke to the issue
  • FDA would contradict Congress if ordered ban
  • not giving deference to substnace of agency's statements, but Congress used agency's statements in making law
  • larger scheme: tobacco's role in economy
  • Dissent: appropriate for FDA to consider new Evidence 
Term
Young v. Community Nuturition Institute
Definition

 

  • ambiguity in FDCA dealing with power of FDA to set tolerance levels for poisonous substances in food
  • FDA refused to set tolerance level
  • SCOTUS agreed there was sufficient ambiguity to defer to FDA's interpretation
  • "shall" is not a clear congressional mandate 
Term

Massachusetts v. EPA (II)

 

Definition
  • This is not like Willaimson because (1) EPA jurisdictoin would not lead to extreme measure as was hte case in Williamson; (2) court in Williamson pointed to unbroken series of Congressional enactments 
Term
Chevron Facts and Holding
Definition
  • CAA required non attainment states to establish a permit program regulating new/modified major sationary sources of pollutin and EPA allows states to treat all pollution emitting devices within same industry grouping as single bubble
  • stationary source: bubble idea
  • court allowed stationary source idea- deference 
Term
2 steps of Chevron
Definition
  • (1) whether Congress has spoken to precise question at issue (INS v. Cardoza, Brown and Williamson)
  • (2) if statute is silent/ambiguous with respect to a specific issue, question for the court is whether agency's answer is based on permissible construction fo the statute
  • not clear what permissible means- range of deference 
Term
NLRB v. Hearst
Definition
  • NLRB orders Hearst to bargin collectively wiht newsboys
  • split between question of law and fact
  • NLRA doesn't include common law understanding of independent contractor
  • court not second guessing congress
  • no definition of employee in NLRA
  • majority thinks Congress intentionally left open what an employee is for NLRB to decide- deference 
Term
Skidmore
Definition
  • Private firefighters sued defendant to recover overtime pay when they had to wait in hall overnight
  • must give some deference to agency 
  • agency issued interpretive bulletin explaining opinion- unlike Hearst because responding generally
  • interpretive bulletin not controlling, but court gives deference because of agency's expertise 
Term
Express Delegation
Definition
  • Congress explicitly left gap for agency to fill 
Term
Implicit delegation
Definition
  • court cannot substitute its own statutory construction for reasonable interpretation by agency 
Term
Babbitt v. Sweet Home Chapter of Communities for a Great Oregon
Definition
  • ESA makes it unlawful for anyone to take a species
  • secretary of interior issues reg to define harm to mean habitat modification- broadens agency reach
  • SCOTUS upheld definition because: (1) ordinary understanding of harm supports it; (2) broad prupsoe of ESA supports secretary's decision; (3) 10(a)(1)(B) of ESA strongly suggsts Congress understood 9(a)(1)(B) to prohibit indirect as well as deliberate takings
  • Dissent: expansion of take- stretch beyond Congressional intent 
Term
INS v. Cardoza- Fonseca
Definition
  • Court refused to find ambiguity in provision of refugee act authorizing INS to grant asylum to an alien becauase of well founded fear of prosecution in his homeland
  • not agency's job to interpret statutory language- that is the court's job 
Term
Chevron Step 2
Definition
  • Courts defer to agency's interpretation of law and that deference is strong- allowing agencies leeway in interpretation
  • Young v. Community Nutrition
  • Babbitt 
Term
Difference between Skidmore, Mead and Chevron
Definition
  • Skidmore and Mead are different from Chevron because of level of formality in agency used in coming to rule or reg 
  • Skidmore and mead- agency has judgment on particular set of facts; EPA reg in Chevron was broader and publicly presented; decisions in Skidmore and Mead are more narrow 
Term
US v. Mead
Definition
  • Day planners were originally categorized as other which meant duty free- now diary has 4% tariff
  • ruling letter issued (different from reg) - not subject to notice and comment; issued 10,000 per year so subject to less Chevron deference- fi court gave Chevron deference to all of these almost total deference to agency and court does not think that is what Congress wanted
  • Skidmore deference is halfway point
  • rulign letters did not bind third parties
  • court gives some consideration to agency's interpretation because of experience 
Term
Wehn to apply Chevron deference
Definition
  • Congress delegated authority to agency generally to make rules carrying force of law and agency's interpretation claiming deference was promulgated in the exercise of that authority
Supporting users have an ad free experience!